The subject today: a heavily muscled bearded man in a white tank top and ripped jeans, hands on hips

Study № 001Vol. 1 · peer-reviewed*

Sports supplements that actually work

A 10-year study of one formerly skinny guy.

Abstract. One subject. Ten years. Every powder the big guy at the gym swore by. What worked, what did nothing, and what only made his wallet lighter. Conflict of interest: the subject really likes chicken.

Read the study

* Reviewed by two guys at the squat rack.

§ 1Methods · participantFig. 1

Same guy. Ten years apart.

Finding

Year0
Body mass
Supplements on the shelf
15
Hours of sleep
5.5
Beard
5 %

Pictures of earlier years are reconstructed from one photograph.

Scroll the page or drag the slider

§ 2ResultsTable 1

The full label.

Everything the subject swallowed in ten years, on one honest label. Flip the switch to see what survived peer review.

15tubs on the shelf
$234a month*

strong evidence some, modest weak or none

* Approximate prices. Evidence rating is editorial, based on ISSN, IOC and Australian Institute of Sport positions.

Supplement Facts*
Serving size: 1 formerly skinny guy
Servings per decade: about 3,650
Amount per dayEvidence

    * Actual ones. † Every statement has a published source: see References. ‡ Daily value of excuses not established.

    § 3.1ResultsApparatus 1

    Protein: the bricks.

    Muscle is a wall that gets knocked down and rebuilt every day. Training tells the crew to build. Protein is the bricks. No bricks, no wall — and past a certain point, the extra bricks just pile up on the pavement.

    A scoop of vanilla protein powder with dust rising
    PROVENISSN · IOC · AIS
    Apparatus 1 — the wall

    The plateau found in trials, not a model of your body.

    • 1.6–2.2 g/kga day is where extra protein stops adding muscle: 49 trials, 1,863 people.5
    • ≈ 0.4 g/kg per mealacross four meals. A guideline, not a ceiling.6
    • The “window” is hours wideA garage door, not a mail slot: the daily total matters most.7
    • Food countsPowder is a convenience, not a requirement.4
    • Healthy kidneys cope28 papers, 1,358 people: no change in kidney function in healthy adults.8
    • Plants work tooAt 1.6 g/kg, vegans and omnivores gained the same over 12 weeks.10

    Your number

    Goal
    Per day128–176 g
    Per meal × 4≈ 32 g

    Now hit it with food

    0/ 128 g

      Protein values from USDA FoodData Central, rounded.

      § 3.2ResultsApparatus 2–3

      Creatine: the fast charger.

      Your muscles burn ATP and keep only a couple of seconds' worth in stock. Phosphocreatine recharges it on the spot — for roughly the first ten seconds of all-out work. Creatine makes that tank 20–40 % bigger. That's the whole trick.

      A small scoop in a pile of white creatine powder
      PROVEN500+ papers
      Apparatus 2 — one all-out set
      Phosphocreatine tank
      0reps

      Apparatus 3 — filling the tank

      • 3–5 g a dayEvery day. Time of day barely matters.1
      • Loading is optionalIt only gets you to the same place sooner.2
      • Plain monohydrateNothing fancier has beaten it.1
      • Vegetarians gain moreLower starting stores, usually a bigger response.1

      Warnings that did not hold up

      § 3.3ResultsApparatus 4

      BCAA: a switch, not a supply truck.

      BCAA are three of the nine essential amino acids. One of them, leucine, flips the “build” switch. But a switch does not deliver materials: building takes all nine, and BCAA bring three.

      A glass of bright blue sports drink with ice
      REDUNDANTif you eat enough protein
      Apparatus 4 — the assembly line
      “Build” signal
      New muscle protein

      • “Unwarranted”is what a 2017 review called the claim that BCAA alone build muscle in humans.11
      • +22 % over placebofrom 5.6 g of BCAA after training — a smaller response than whey usually gives.12
      • Enough protein, no benefitWith adequate daily protein, extra BCAA add nothing measurable.13
      • The switch is in the scoopWhey protein is about 11 % leucine already.4
      • Group Cis where the Australian Institute of Sport files BCAA: evidence does not support a benefit.29
      • To be fairThey may ease soreness a little. Results are inconsistent.14

      THE SUBJECT'S RECEIPT

      BCAA, 36 months$936*

      Muscle attributable0 g

      FlavorBlue Razz

      * Approximate amount. It did taste nice.

      The most expensive lemonade of his life.

      § 3.4ResultsApparatus 5

      Caffeine: the tiredness blocker.

      Caffeine does not add energy. It blocks adenosine — the molecule that tells your brain it is tired — from docking. Effort feels smaller, so you do more work. The catch is on the clock.

      Coffee beans spilling from a scoop with white caffeine tablets
      PROVENmind the clock
      Apparatus 5 — the clock

      Half-life taken as 5 hours; it varies widely between people. Body weight comes from the protein calculator.

      • 3–6 mg/kgabout an hour before training. From 9 mg/kg up you add side effects, not performance.15
      • ≈ +3 % powerin endurance trials. Strength effects are smaller.16
      • An hour of sleep, gone400 mg six hours before bed cost over an hour of sleep — and people did not notice.17
      • ≈ 400 mg a dayis the amount the FDA cites for most healthy adults.31
      • On the doping list until 2004It works well enough to have been banned.15

      § 3.5Supplementary materialsTable 2

      The rest of the aisle.

      Fifteen more products from the supplement aisle, fifteen verdicts. Tap a card and it turns over.

      § 4Peer review8 questions

      Peer review: you are Reviewer 2.

      Eight claims from the locker room. Bro science, or actual science? The subject is watching.

      Drag the card, or use the ← → keys.

      § 5Conclusion

      95 %showing up. 5 %supplements. 0 %magic.

      The author's estimate, not a measurement. The trials above are the measurements.

      Limitations of this study

      1. Sample size: one.
      2. No control group. The subject refused to stay skinny.
      3. Not blinded. He owns a mirror.
      4. Funding: his own wallet. See Table 1.
      5. Results may not generalize to people who skip leg day.

      § 6Replicationn = 2: now you

      Replicate the study.

      Enter a couple of numbers and get your own label. The short one — with nothing on it that does not work.

      Goal
      Diet
      Caffeine

      Educational content, not medical advice. Under 18, pregnant, or managing a medical condition — kidneys especially? Ask a doctor first.

      Drag to spin the tub

      Appendix

      The whole library.

      Every supplement, every question and every calculator on its own page, with the sources.

      Supplements

      Beet Juice for PerformanceHow beetroot juice nitrate affects endurance, how much nitrate and when to take it, and why trained athletes may see smaller gains. Sources: IOC and AIS.WorksBeta-Alanine BenefitsWhat beta-alanine does, how much to take, why it makes your skin tingle and which efforts it helps. Doses and effects come from the ISSN position stand.WorksCaffeine Before a WorkoutHow much caffeine to take before a workout, when to take it, how big the effect is and how late is too late for sleep. Doses from the ISSN position stand.WorksCreatine MonohydrateWhat creatine monohydrate does, how much to take, whether loading is needed and what the safety data say, with every claim tied to a published source.WorksSodium Bicarbonate for PerformanceHow much sodium bicarbonate to take, when to take it, which efforts it helps and why a bigger dose only adds stomach trouble. From the ISSN position stand.WorksAshwagandha for Strength and RecoveryAshwagandha for strength: a meta-analysis of 13 studies found benefits over placebo in healthy people, with caveats. What it shows and where it stops.DependsCitrulline MalateWhat citrulline malate does for training, how much to take and when, and how large the effect really is, based on a meta-analysis of 8 studies.DependsVitamin D for AthletesVitamin D for athletes: what the IOC and the AIS actually say about dose and need, and why it is a medical supplement rather than a performance one.DependsWhey Protein PowderIs whey protein powder worth it? How much protein you need, how much per serving, and what studies say about timing, kidneys and plant alternatives.DependsBCAA BenefitsDo BCAAs build muscle or ease soreness? A look at the research on branched-chain amino acids, how they compare with protein and where the AIS files them.Skip itCollagen Protein vs Whey Protein for MuscleCollagen vs whey protein: in healthy older women, whey raised muscle protein synthesis and collagen peptides did not. Leucine content compared.Skip itDo Testosterone Boosters Work? What Data ShowDo testosterone boosters work? A review of 50 products found published data showing an increase for only 24.8 percent. What that, and AIS Group D, mean.Skip itGlutamine BenefitsDoes glutamine build muscle? A meta-analysis of 25 trials found no effect on lean or fat mass. Here is what that means for your shelf and your wallet.Skip itHMB SupplementDoes HMB work? A review of 6 studies in trained and competitive athletes found no effect on strength or body composition, and the AIS files it in Group C.Skip itZMA SupplementDoes ZMA work? A study of 42 resistance-trained men found no significant change in strength or in total or free testosterone. Here is what that means.Skip it

      Questions

      Anabolic WindowAnabolic window explained: why protein timing after a workout matters little once daily protein is matched, and what to do about when you eat it.QuestionAre BCAAs Worth It? What the Research SaysAre BCAAs worth it for muscle growth? With enough total protein, studies show no apparent benefit. What the evidence says about BCAA vs protein.Skip itAre Supplements FDA Approved? What Is CheckedAre supplements FDA approved? The FDA does not review them for safety or effectiveness before sale. What that means, and what labels and seals can tell you.QuestionCreatine Loading PhaseCreatine loading phase explained: the standard protocol, the slower 28-day route, what loading costs on the scale and why it is not required.QuestionIs Creatine a Steroid? Common Myths CheckedIs creatine a steroid? Creatine myths checked against the published research: steroids, dehydration, cramps, fat gain, special forms and loading.QuestionDoes Creatine Cause Hair Loss? What the Trial FoundDoes creatine cause hair loss? Where the DHT worry came from, what a 2025 randomized trial measured on the scalp, and what it cannot tell you.QuestionDoes Creatine Make You Gain Weight? Water vs FatDoes creatine make you gain weight? A loading phase typically adds 1–3 kg, mainly water, and no fat. Here is what the research says about the weight.QuestionDoes Sleep Affect Muscle Growth? One Night's DataDoes sleep affect muscle growth? One night without sleep cut muscle protein synthesis by 18 % in a small study. What it shows, and what it does not.QuestionHow Long Does Caffeine Last? Half-Life and SleepHow long does caffeine last in your body? The half-life is about 5 hours and varies widely. What a sleep study found for 400 mg taken before bed.QuestionHow Much Protein Per Day to Build MuscleHow much protein per day to build muscle: the RDA minimum, the ISSN range for people who train, where the gains level off, and the deficit figure.QuestionHow Much Protein Per Meal for Muscle GrowthHow much protein per meal: the 0.25 g/kg or 20–40 g guideline, the per-meal arithmetic behind 1.6 and 2.2 g/kg a day, and one 100 g study in context.QuestionIs Creatine Bad for Your Kidneys? What Studies SayIs creatine bad for your kidneys? What the long-term safety record shows in healthy people, what it does not cover, and when to ask a doctor.QuestionIs Too Much Protein Bad for Your Kidneys?Does a high-protein diet harm healthy kidneys? What a review of 28 studies found, where the evidence stops, and when it is time to ask a doctor.QuestionMass Gainer vs Protein PowderMass gainer vs protein powder: both are sports foods in the AIS framework, convenient but not special. What each is for and how to choose.QuestionWhey vs Plant ProteinWhey vs plant protein for muscle: a 12-week trial of 19 vegans and 19 omnivores found no difference in lean mass or strength. Details and limits.QuestionSupplements That Actually WorkWhich gym supplements actually work? A tiered list from the IOC consensus and the AIS framework, from creatine and caffeine down to products to avoid.QuestionWhen to Take CreatineWhen to take creatine: what the ISSN says about timing, why taking it with carbohydrate, or carbohydrate plus protein, may help retention, and what matters.Question

      Calculators